Editor/Publisher
Phi Beta Gas Cap
VW-XYZ was a forum to raise questions that had motorists—or their mechanics—stumped. Regular features included CARtharsis, a place for readers to voice their opinions and vent their frustration; Phi Beta Gas Cap, honoring talented and trustworthy mechanics; First Aid, offering antidotes for common ailments and autopsies for terminal illnesses; Lemons, to console owners of incurable vehicles; and VW-ABCs, confronting the little things that don’t need an expert’s help.
Uncomfortable with home remedies? Less than sanguine about costly repairs? Then you might be candidate for itinerant mechanics who make house calls. Welcome to the world of Magnanimous Mobile Mechanics!
ARTICLE
Magnanimous Mobile Mechanics
This story is about street mechanics—mobile merchants of auto repair who can perform magic in the middle of the Mission...or the Marina...or even Market Street. It’s about low overhead (working out of their homes) and no overhead (working outdoors). For VW owners on a budget, street mechanics provide a middle ground between doing it yourself and conventional, costlier avenues of repair. They appeal to penny-pinchers, to lazybones, to do-it-yourselfers who have bungled tune-ups and who can’t face their regular mechanics, and to people who just would like to stick it to the $48/hour garages.
Working for combinations of cash or barter, street mechanics offer basic services at unbeatable prices. Some whom we surveyed charge as little as $25 (plus parts) for a tune-up, $20-$25 to adjust valves, only $4 to adjust brakes, and $17/wheel to re-sole worn brake shoes.
For various fees, many also will come to the aid of motorists in distress—the “won’t starts,” the rainy-day problems, and the after-effects of failed attempts at self-repair.
The best of them also are equipped—and qualified—to perform major functions, replacing transmissions and overhauling engines. Some are capable of rebuilding entire cars.
For large jobs, their prices are as varied as the mechanics themselves. It can be a flat rate. Or it can be an hourly rate that, usually around $25, is flat-out cheap.
And though inexpensive, street mechanics are not necessarily inexperienced. For reasons of independence or—particularly nowadays—unemployment, they are in business for themselves.
Some, on the other hand, are salaried mechanics with nine-to-five jobs who moonlight to earn extra income. They have to operate word-of-mouth—employers frown upon outside work for fear of being undercut.
If you’re shopping for a street mechanic, you might check the want ads in newspapers or advertising shoppers, or look for fliers or business cards on your car’s windshield. And take note of the names and numbers of the mechanics below.
You won’t find them in the Yellow Pages.
Emergency Service
Meet Dave Russell. He’s a 27-year-old mechanic who lives near City College and who has been fixing cars since he was 13.
Russell works on all makes and models. He operates out of the two-car garage of his Sunnyside home, makes emergency calls (phone 377-1575) and will arrange free towing for jobs over $100.
“The reason I became a street mechanic,” says Russell, “was that I could spend more time with my family—I have three young kids.
“I also can spend more time with my customers. Because I can take my time, I do a good job and I don’t miss anything. I’m very conscientious.”
Russell moved to San Francisco seven years ago from his native Arlington, Va., where he worked for a large, independent garage catering to Volkswagens and specializing in engine rebuilding.
“A shop is like a machine—in/out, in/out,” says Russell. “You come in and say, ‘I want this,’ and they spit out the job whether or not they ever fix the problem.
“Everything is rush, rush, rush.”
Working on his own, Russell says he can offer better service. His only advertising is a classified ad which reads, “Mechanic, foreign, domestic. Good work/good rates.”
A tune-up generally runs $35-$40, he says, and includes new plugs, points “and a spark plug wire or two if it needs it.” Often, the job is done in conjunction with a valve adjustment ($20-$25) and an oil change ($10).
For brake jobs, he charges $30-$35 for a pair of new front or rear linings. The job includes examining the wheel cylinders, deglazing the drums, and packing the wheel bearings.
“I’m a lot cheaper than most anybody else,” Russell says. “I pay the same rent here whether or not I repair cars.
“I usually flat-rate everything,” he adds. “I can look at a job and I know roughly what the parts are going to cost and I add enough labor for what I think the job is worth.”
Russell says he likes to mix a large job—”I can change a transaxle or whole front ends; if somebody wants it done, I’ll do it”—with several small jobs. He sets a limit of three jobs per day, and usually the business is there.
“Things have a funny way of working out for me,” he says. “The more work I need, the more there is.
“If I don’t need anything, it slows down.”
Dose of Medicine
The ”Bug Doctor,” to whom we award four stars and a Phi Beta Gas Cap [see story, page 19], is a 52-year-old mechanic who lives in the Western Addition and who prefers to be known by his trade name.
His calling card reads, “House Calls Only,” and he functions strictly as a dial-a-mechanic (phone 552-4169). Although he specializes in Bugs, his practice includes many other models of Volkswagen.
His sick ward is the avenues and alleys of San Francisco. And, weather permitting, he’s on call weekdays and weekends, dispensing aid and advice with the help of an answering machine and a pager.
He believes you solve problems by going to the problems.
“I go to someone’s home, get in their car, and drive it,” he says. “If it won’t start, I’m there.
“If they drive the same car to a repair shop and it’s halfway running, the mechanic will ask, ‘What’s wrong with it?—it’s running right now.’ And he can troubleshoot that thing all day long and maybe find the problem, and maybe not.”
The Bug Doctor only works on Volkswagens.
“I’m looking at Volkswagens all the time,” he says. “I know what things should look like and exactly how they should be functioning.
“I can just pop the hood sometimes and, ah-hah, there’s the problem.”
His basic rate is $25/hour. The minimum for diagnosing a problem: $15.
“Because I represent the next thing in terms of price above doing it yourself, I get a lot of do-it-yourself ‘oops’ business,” he says. An example: person gets the old muffler off but can’t get the new one on.
Most of my work involves trouble-shooting. And troubleshooting is a basic $25/hour situation until I find the problem. But many times I take a bend on that in terms of actual work versus the time finding the problem.
“If I don’t find the problem, which is rare, I will say, ‘I don’t find it,’ and I’ll charge just the minimum. I’ve done that in some instances after troubleshooting for two hours.”
If that happens, he then will discuss the problem with other mechanics—what’s known as “bench racing.” If that fails, he’ll seek solutions “anywhere I feel I might get information.”
The Bug Doctor’s background includes a stint as a VW mechanic at a dealership in Culver City. He joined the local scene about two years ago and makes his rounds in a '60 Bug that “has been to the moon and back several times.”
“When you’re in the street, you’re an entrepreneur,” he says. “You call your own shots...set your own hours. You don’t have a garage to open at 9 in the morning.”
The road service helps to build up his regular business (tune-ups are $55, plus parts), although he says he tries to limit his work to four calls a day. Despite a substantial following, he’s steadfast about remaining a street mechanic.
“I do not envy, nor do I wish to join, anybody in the shop—unless somewhere down the road the government or the various agencies force me to.
“I’m certain I could pass any mechanical exam in the world—that’s no problem. The difficulty with me is the continual hassle of overhead and all the stuff that goes on when you’re in business.”
His only investment as a mobile mechanic is in tools. And that, he says, “was covered years ago.”
Garage Sale
To qualify as a customer for Jay Parker, a 39-year-old mechanic who works out of his home in the Miraloma Park section, you probably should own a '65 to '70 Beetle. Parker, whose personal car is a '65 Bug, has made this his subspecialty.
While he’ll consider VWs from other years and in other forms, Parker, who has 15 years’ experience repairing cars, is not lacking for customers. His prices, lowest of those surveyed, no doubt draws a lot of inquiries (phone 564-5917).
Tune-ups are $25 and include a valve adjustment; brake adjustments are $5; brake relines, $17/wheel; and clutch installation, $100 plus parts.
Parker says a tune-up takes about an hour and 15 minutes.
“That’s why I figure $25,” he says. “That doesn’t include things like checking the battery and windshield fluid levels or the air in the tires—my customers can do the themselves.
“There’s a lot of stuff you can throw into a tune-up to make it more expensive, but that’s not my purpose. And I don’t think that’s what my customers want.
“I think they want the important things done: the timing, points, valves.”
He describes himself as a “minimum parts replacer.”
“Some mechanics automatically throw in new distributor caps and new rotors and new fuel filters,” he says. “I do that only if I see something is disintegrating. And I’ve never had a tune-up come back because it was lacking in new parts.”
The typical customer’s bill comes to $40, says Parker.
“When I get a regular customer’s car, one of the first things I do is check the brake pedal. Very often when they come in for a tune-up they’re going to need a brake adjustment.
If it needs to be relined, that’s the time to tell them.”
He believes most people who go to street mechanics are bargain-hunters.
“Let’s face it,” he says, “they’re cheapskates.
“Some of my customers still are not used to $25 tune-ups because it used to be $20. They say, ‘Come on, Jay, it used to be $20. They know what the prices are out in the real world, but still they try to get me lower.”
When he started in San Francisco around 1970, he charged $7 for the same thing.
“I moved here from San Jose and didn’t have a job,” he recalls. “So I had some business cards printed up and started doing tune-ups.
“I distributed 1,000 cards, and the response was about one customer per 100 cards.”
Since then, whenever he’s needed more customers, he’s gone to Stonestown Shopping Center and put out a few hundred cards.
Parker mostly works out of his home off Portola Drive. He has about 25 steady customers—enough to pay the $200/month rent for the apartment and garage.
By contrast, he says, rent for a commercial garage is $500/month and up.
“That means they have to make at least $500 just to pay for the location,” says Parker. “Some months, I can get by on just $500 a month.”
He has a very frugal lifestyle.
“Most people would say, ‘How can this guy live on just $500? But my rent is only $200 and I spend $150 a month on food.
“I could probably get by on $400 a month.”
Parker, who describes himself as a “vegetarian Volkswagen auto mechanic,” says he could never work in a shop—his way of doing things is “too unconventional.”
He works on a come-as-you-go basis.
“You can call me Saturday or Sunday morning—I make myself accessible.
“I’ve heard stories about how hard some shops make it for customers. My customers tell me, ‘You make it so easy compared to others.’”
They are welcome to drop their cars off at any hour of the day. If it’s early enough, he’ll get the work done in time for them to pick it up at night.
“If I’m not going to be here,” he says, “I’ll leave the key with the landlady.”
A Scholar and a Repairman
There’s one other mobile merchant you should know about. He’s Joe Amador, and he advertises his services as follows: “Quality body work. Free est. I’ll beat any est. by 20-50%. Try me. 871-6445.”
Those who do will find an enterprising young man of 25 who grew up in the Mission on a block surrounded by body shops. He learned the trade by “talking to workers on their lunch breaks,” practiced on his own cars and, when he had sufficient skills, landed a job in one of the shops.
“I’m not one of those guys who hustle on the street and just put big blobs of body filler in your dents,” says Amador. “I know how to do a good job, and I do it. I don’t cut any corners.”
Amador is a part-time student in accounting at Skyline College in San Bruno. He says he works on cars “to make a little money and to have a lot of fun.” He also derives pleasure, he says, from helping car owners save on repairs.
“They see my ad in the paper which says I’ll beat anybody’s estimates, and I will. I usually save people on the average of $500 for major work.”
Amador says he charges $15/hour to do the same work for which shops charge $40-$50.
“Body shops charge different people different prices,” he notes. “If they need the work, they charge you less; if they don’t, they charge you more.
“If it’s an insurance job, there’s one price. If you’re paying for it, there’s another.”
He says many of his customers are married couples in their late 20’s and early 30’s—often living in the Sunset—who have families and who hold good jobs. “They have an accident and, for some reason, they don’t want to bring it up in front of the insurance company and have their rates go up. So they try to save and have the work done on the side.”
Amador says he likes working at customers’ homes because “they get to see my work.” He also gets to meet a lot of people.
“I’ve met a guy from the Immigration Service, a couple of police officers, a lawyer, you name it. People always tell me, ‘Hey, if you ever need anything, give me a call.
“And they refer me to other customers. People call me up and say, ‘You did so-and-so’s car and I liked the job and I liked the price—would you do mine?’
“Sometimes old customers call up and ask how business is going and tell me a friend of theirs wants some body work done. They seem to feel like they’re doing their friends a favor by introducing them to me because I do things cheaper.”